Menu Close

Metal Roofs vs. Shingles

If you are in search of a new roof, you might wonder the type of roof that would work best for your property. Metal roofs and shingles are incredible roofing options. However, they are quite different and it is important for you to understand the distinctions, so that you can know the best roof for you. This article weighs down the advantages and disadvantages of metal roofs and shingles.


The first factor you need to look at when differentiating between metal roofs and shingles is the cost of installation. Metal roofs are more expensive when you consider them as a one-time cost. However, they do help you save money in the long term. The main reason behind this is that one metal roof can easily outlast three shingle roofs.

As aforementioned, shingles are cheaper than metal roofing as a one-time cost, a factor that many homeowners find appealing. Nevertheless, shingle roofing will cost you more in the long term, as you have to do regular maintenance and replace more frequently than metal roofs.


Metal roofs are quite strong and can stand up to anything. Due to this, they can last for over 50 years. Nevertheless, falling branches and extreme hail could create dents on your metal roof. It can also be harmed if you regularly walk on it improperly.

On the other hand, shingles have a shorter lifespan compared to metal roofs. In fact, they have a lifetime of between 15 and 30 years. Damp conditions and pooling water can lead to growth of fungus and algae growth. Temperature spikes and ice dams can also reduce the life of your shingle by creating cracks.

Energy Efficiency

Asphalt and shingles work differently when exposed to different climates. Metal roofing is seen to work well in hot climates. In fact, the material is able to keep a house much cooler than shingles do. The main reason behind this is that metal is able to reflect sunlight, keeping your home cool. On the other hand, shingles absorb heat, making a house hotter.

Since shingles absorb heat, they help keep a house warm during winter. Nevertheless, with the right insulation, metal roofing could do the same. Furthermore, the EPA has shown significant energy savings of a metal roof, meaning that energy spending will still be low with metal roof, despite the fact that more heating is needed.

Ease of Installation

Metal roofing is quite tough to install, and often requires an experienced contractor to do the work. Finding a professional contractor is very important because most metal roofing issues come because of installation errors. When compared to shingle installers, very few professionals possess the right skills to install metal roofing.
Shingles need little labor and time for both replacement and installation. The main reason behind this is that they come prepackaged and ready to be nailed to the deck. If you working with metal roofing, then you ought to handle finished panels, connect panels together using screws, and later install the flashing. This work requires more skill, labor, and time on the part of the installer.


Metal roofs happen to be more eco-friendly than shingles because they are mostly made of recycled material. In addition, since metal roofs are more sustainable, there is not much replacement that needs to be done, meaning minimal metal materials are released into the environment.

Shingles, on the other hand, require frequent replacement, meaning a lot of asphalt shingles are released into the environment. In fact, the United States receives over 20 billion pounds of shingles every year. Furthermore, shingles are petroleum-based, which increases the country’s dependency on fossil fuels.


One of the greatest differences between shingles and metal roofing is lifespan. Normally, metal roofing is expected to last for over 50 years before degradation signs start showing. There are metal materials such as zinc and copper that can last over 100 years. On the other hand, shingles last a maximum of 25 years, and this material is highly prone to wear and tear.

When it is time to install a new roof, the numerous options in the market can be overwhelming to you. Metal roofing has long been known for its longevity and durability. On the other hand, shingles are famous for their reliability, ease of maintenance, and cost-effectiveness. Although both materials are great for roofing, one may be better, depending on what you are looking for. Thus, comparing the features might help you make the best decision for your roof.

Related Posts